How we work

Technology readiness is only half the path to deployment

Technology readiness versus adoption readinessTwo axes, Technology Readiness Level (TRL) from 1 to 9 vertically and Adoption Readiness Level (ARL) from 1 to 9 horizontally. Deployment sits at the top right, where both are high. A technology development-focused strategy climbs the TRL axis only; a deployment-focused strategy climbs both together. The area between them is what TRL progress leaves unresolved.DeploymentTechnology development-focused strategyWhat TRL progressleaves unresolvedDeployment-focused strategyResearch336699Adoption Readiness Level (ARL)Technology Readiness Level (TRL)
Department of Energy, Office of Technology Commercialization: Adoption Readiness Level framework

What is ARL?

The Department of Energy's Adoption Readiness Level (ARL) is a complement to Technology Readiness Level (TRL). It classifies 17 adoption risks into four groups: value proposition, market acceptance, resource maturity, license to operate.

Why both axes

Both scales must reach the top for deployment, but while TRL advances through science and engineering, ARL advances through business operations like costing the plant, sizing the market, testing the supply chain, and structuring the capital.

The Adoption Readiness Level track is where we work.

Clearing the path to deployment and where we work

The 17 Adoption Readiness Level dimensions, and how much of each group MODULE12 covers.

  • MODULE12 core coverage
  • MODULE12 partial coverage
  • Not covered

MODULE12 core coverage

Value Proposition

Can the technology deliver what the market needs, at a price customers will pay?

  • Delivered Cost

    Achieving delivered cost competitiveness when produced at full scale

  • Functional Performance

    Ability to meet or exceed the performance and feature-set of incumbent solutions, or create new end-use markets

  • Ease of Use / Complexity

    Operational switching costs; the ability of a new user to adopt and operationalize the technology with limited training

MODULE12 core coverage

Market Acceptance

Who are the buyers? How large is the market? Who already holds it?

  • Demand Maturity / Market Openness

    Demand certainty and access to standardized sales and contracting mechanisms, as well as natural and structural barriers to entry

  • Market Size

    Overall size of the market that can be served by the technology, and the level of uncertainty with which it will materialize

  • Downstream Value Chain

    Projected path to get the product from a producer to a customer along the value chain

MODULE12 core coverage

Resource Maturity

Do the inputs exist to build and run it at scale?

  • Capital Flow

    Availability of capital to move from current state to production at scale, including required investment, willing investors, and speed of capital flow

  • Workforce

    Human capital and capabilities required to design, produce, install, maintain, and operate the technology solution at scale

  • Materials Sourcing

    Availability of required critical materials

  • Manufacturing and Supply Chain

    All the entities and processes that will produce the end-product, including integrators, component and sub-component manufacturers

  • Infrastructure

    Physical and digital large-scale systems that need to be in place to support, enable or facilitate deployment at scale

  • Project Development, Integration, and Management

    Processes and capabilities to successfully and repeatably execute projects using the technology solution

MODULE12 partial coverage

License to Operate

What are the societal and regulatory conditions for deploying at all?

  • Permitting and Siting

    Process to secure approvals to site and build equipment and infrastructure associated with deploying the technology at scale

  • Community Perception

    The general perception by global and local communities of the technology and its risks or impact, whether founded or unfounded

  • Regulatory EnvironmentNot covered

    Local, state, and federal regulations or other requirements and standards that must be met to deploy the technology at scale

  • Policy EnvironmentNot covered

    Local, state, and federal government policy actions that support or hinder the adoption of the technology at scale

  • Environmental and SafetyNot covered

    The potential for hazardous side effects or adverse events inherent to the production, transport, or use of the technology in the absence of sufficient controls

Department of Energy, Office of Technology Commercialization: Adoption Readiness Level framework, core risk areas.

Our method

We give you the answer, and the tools to adapt when it changes.

How we work

Four steps, run in order on every engagement

  1. 01

    Frame the decision

  2. 02

    Build it bottom-up

  3. 03

    Test it to breaking

  4. 04

    Deliver a strategy

Options in

  • Development strategies
  • Financing routes
  • Partnerships
  • Adjacent markets
  • Spin-offs & side revenues
  • Market entry options

Where we guide your business

Four domains, screened together to raise your ARL

  • TEA

    What it really costs to build and run: FOAK and Nth-of-a-kind

  • Market & commercialization

    Who buys, at what price, for how long, and which path to take

  • Financial model & financing

    Returns for equity and debt, and a financing plan across milestones

  • Risk & scenarios

    What breaks, how likely, and what it costs when it does

The paths worth taking

Re-tested as conditions change.